Candy Key

choco_preztelsHave you ever gotten a box of our chocolates and wondered what was inside each of our fine chocolates? Here is the answer to all those questions, a listing of all the chocolates we sell. All of our candies are made at our downtown store facility and are hand marked for distinction.

All items are subject to availability

Gourmet Truffles

Milk Chocolate Banana Cream Pie

This truffle has a chocolate covered banana filling
Available in Milk Chocolate

Milk Chocolate Champagne

This milk truffle has a sweet creamy center with a hint of champagne flavoring
Available in Milk Chocolate

Milk Chocolate Chocolate

This milk truffle has a sweet milk chocolate frosting flavored center
Available in Milk Chocolate

Milk Chocolate Coffee

This milk chocolate truffle has rich mocha espresso flavor
Available in Milk Chocolate

Milk Chocolate German Chocolate

This milk truffle has a sweet chocolate center with bits of almond toffee and coconut mixed throughout
Available in Milk Chocolate

Milk Chocolate Hazelnut

This milk truffle has a milk chocolate and hazelnut flavored ganache center
Available in Milk Chocolate

Milk Mint Chocolate Chip

This seasonal truffle features a refreshing mint center with bits of dark chocolate inside.
Available in Milk Chocolate

Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter

This peanut flavored center is coated in milk chocolate and rolled in our crushed peanuts
Available in Milk Chocolate

Milk Chocolate Praline Pecan

This truffle features a sweet chocolate ganache center with bits of candied pecans mixed in and sprinkled on top
Available in Milk Chocolate

Milk Chocolate Salty Caramel

This popular truffle has a chocolate caramel flavored ganache center and is sprinkled with coarse Sea Salt
Available in Milk Chocolate

Milk Chocolate Strawberry

This seasonal favorite features a fresh strawberry flavor inside.
Available in Milk Chocolate

Dark Chocolate Amaretto

This rich truffle has a dark chocolate center that’s flavored with amaretto liquor
Available in Dark Chocolate

Dark Chocolate Coconut Cream Pie

This dark truffle features a sweet coconut filling with coconut flakes throughout
Available in Dark Chocolate

Dark Chocolate Grand Marnier

This rich truffle has a dark chocolate center flavored with orange liquor
Available in Dark Chocolate

Dark Chocolate Mint

This dark chocolate truffle has a smooth mint flavor
Available in Dark Chocolate

Dark Chocolate Red Hot Cinnamon Truffle

This seasonal truffle has the strong flavor of red hot candies inside.
Available in Dark Chocolate

Dark Chocolate Red Raspberry

This dark chocolate truffle has a sweet raspberry ganache filling
Available in Dark Chocolate

White Frosted Birthday Cake

This sweet truffle has the flavor of buttercream frosting and festive rainbow sprinkles throughout
Available in White Chocolate

Soft Centers

Vanilla Cream

Hand marked with a letter "V" on top, our sweet vanilla cream is one of our most popular creams
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Butter Cream

Marked with a "B" on top, this buttery yellow center has a buttercream frosting flavor to it
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Maple Cream

Marked with a letter "M", this popular cream has an old fashion maple syrup flavor to it
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Chocolate Cream

Marked with a "C" this cream features a smooth and sweet chocolate center
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Orange Cream

Marked with an "O" on top, this flavorful cream has a smooth orange flavored texture that's delightful
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Raspberry Cream

Marked with an "R" on top, this cream has the distinct flavor of fresh red raspberries
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Peppermint Cream

Marked with a "P", this green colored cream has the refreshing flavor of peppermint
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Cherry Cream

Marked with a curly "C" this pink filled cream has a delicious cherry flavor to it
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Chocolate Covered Cherry

This popular favorite is marked with a swirl on top and has a juicy maraschino cherry inside it
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Peanut Butter Meltaway

This sinful treat is square and marked with three lines. It features creamy, rich peanut butter drenched in milk or dark chocolate
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Mint Meltaway

Marked with a letter "M", these treats feature a wonderful smooth fudgy mint center. The perfect after dinner indulgence
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Buckeye

An Ohio tradition, this treat features a peanut butter center that's dunked in milk chocolate to look like a buckeye nut
Available in Milk Chocolate

Marshmallow

Our airy, spongy marshmallow cream is formed into a perfectly smooth dome mold before being coated
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Snowball

This unique item that we make features a vanilla center dipped in dark chocolate and rolled in coconut
Available in Dark Chocolate

Orange Jelly

New to our candy collection, this soft jelly center has a refreshing orange flavor.  It's square shaped and stamped with an "O"
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Raspberry Jelly

New to our candy collection, this soft jelly center has a tart raspberry flavor.  It's square shaped and stamped with an "R"
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Crunchy & Chewy

Caramel

One of our most popular items, this square piece, marked with one line, features a fresh chewy caramel center
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Critter

One of our best sellers, this caramel pecan patty has no markings on the top and lots of chewy caramel and fresh pecans on the inside
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Sea Salt Caramel

One of our best selling candies, this square piece looks like our traditional caramel but has coarse Sea Salt sprinkled on top of it
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Caramel Cluster

Similar to the other filled clusters, this treat has a chewy caramel center covered in peanuts and chocolate
Available in Milk Chocolate

Nougat

This thick rectangular piece is marked with one line and has a dense marshmallow based center with black walnut pieces in it
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Toffee Square

This thick square piece is marked with two lines and has a hard buttery toffee center with pieces of almonds in it
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Honeycomb Chip

This popular item is a slim shaped rectangle with one line across the top. The hard honeycomb center tastes like molasses
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Peanut Butter Chip

This thin rectangular shaped item has no markings across the top and a hard peanut butter flavored center
Available in Milk Chocolate

Mint Chip

This slim rectangular shaped piece has two lines across the top and has a hard candy center that tastes like peppermint
Available in Dark Chocolate
Available in White Chocolate

Coconut Clusters

This popular treat, also known as a "haystack", features fresh shredded coconut blended with chocolate
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Almond Buttercrunch

This square piece has no markings on it because the rich toffee center is coated in almond pieces
Available in Milk Chocolate

Cashew Buttercrunch

Similar to the almond version, this square piece has no markings on it because the rich toffee center is coated in cashew pieces
Available in Milk Chocolate

Peanut Clusters

One of our most popular items, this salty and sweet combination has fresh roasted, slightly salted, Spanish peanuts inside
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Almond Clusters

This nut cluster is distinguished by the oval shaped, fresh roasted almonds it has inside of it
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Pecan Clusters

This nut cluster has fresh roasted, slightly salted, pecan pieces inside it
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Cashew Clusters

This nut cluster has no distinguishing marks, just freshly roasted, slightly salted golden cashew pieces inside it
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Hazelnut Clusters

Fresh roasted hazelnuts, also known as filberts, grouped in clusters of three or four, make up this nutty treat
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Macadamia Clusters

We cluster three or four of these large fresh roasted rich nuts with milk chocolate to create a real tropical treat
Available in Milk Chocolate

Maple Clusters

One of our biggest sellers, this treat is a combination of fresh peanuts, maple cream and chocolate
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Vanilla Clusters

Similar in appearance to maple clusters, this item has a vanilla center, covered in fresh blanched peanuts and chocolate
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Almond Bark

The only distinguishing mark you'll find on our barks are the little bits of uncoated nuts sticking out of the top and sides
Available in White Chocolate
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Pecan Bark

Like our Almond Bark, our Pecan Bark is only distinguished by the pecan pieces sticking out of it
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Graham Crackers

These large square treats have no markings on the top, and a honey graham cracker on the inside
Available in Milk Chocolate

Oreos

These full size Oreos have no markings on the top. This super rich treat is coated in milk chocolate or white confectionery coating
Available in Milk Chocolate
Available in White Chocolate

Chocolate Covered Pretzel

By far our best selling product, these full size pretzels are the perfect salty sweet combination
Available in White Chocolate
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate

Smores Clusters

These clusters feature a combination of mini marshmallows and Golden Grahams cereal inside
Available in Milk Chocolate

Cookies & Cream Bark

This bark is full of Oreo cookie pieces mixed with sweet confectionery coating
Available in White Chocolate

Cocomel

A new addition to our line, this treat features a layer of caramel and chewy coconut with coconut flakes sprinkled on top
Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate